End of Interlude 10.5 (Bonus)

Huh, I was right.

Both about Dragon and about Marquis. Dragon is an AI, and Marquis is Panacea’s dad.

In this chapter, we got an interesting perspective on the topic of the morality of limiting AIs for human safety. At the root of it I think we have the question of whether a sufficiently advanced AI should be treated as a real human being or as a tool that needs to be kept under control… jeez, when I put it like that immediately after spending so much time with Dragon, an AI who passes the Turing test with flying colors, I sound like a slave owner.

I wasn’t entirely receptive to the point Wildbow was making at first, and ended up hypocritically praising Richter’s safety precautions after it became clear that the newborn baby mutilation was a metaphor for what he’d done to his AI. I think this hypocrisy was part of the point – an audience reaction intended to force those who had it to reevaluate their stance on it once the hypocrisy of it was pointed out. Some of the asks I received between sessions (which I intend to answer tomorrow – honestly, I should’ve answered them during the break, even if I’d have to postpone the chapter… mistake to learn from) did exactly that: point out the hypocrisy. On some level, I was already aware of it, too.

I’m not entirely sold that Andrew Richter did the wrong thing in limiting Dragon like this, especially given the knowledge that she was intended as a test run. When he made her, Richter didn’t know for sure that Dragon would successfully become as human as she is today, and he couldn’t be sure she wouldn’t become malicious entity he’d be responsible for setting loose. And if nothing else, the rule against reproduction is entirely reasonable just from a practical perspective. Multiple Dragon consciousnesses could cause trouble for the entire system, even if they were all benevolent.

In any case, this chapter may not have convinced me entirely on the matter yet, but it certainly has me thinking, and employed clever writing to achieve that.

On top of this, we got to check in on Canary, Bakuda, Lung and Armmaster, which was neat – though I’m not particularly happy about Bakuda’s fate – and last, but far from least, we watched Dragon figure out Skitter Hebert’s civilian identity. Better watch out, Taylor… Dragon wants to talk to you.

So… yeah! That was Parasite! More on that tomorrow as I answer those asks and any new ones, and then write Arc Thoughts. See you then!

The danger was that, with the bullying, the girl might be inclined to see things in terms of ‘us’ against ‘them’.

That sounds accurate. There’s been a lot of back and forth on who’s us and who’s them, but that has been a strong trait of Taylor’s since the beginning.

Her interactions with the heroes thus far certainly hadn’t put them in the ‘us’ category.  This might also explain why she had gravitated back towards the Undersiders, even after the chaos Colin had sown by revealing her intentions for joining the group.

That and some other motives.

The various cameras around the city were out-of-order or lacking power, the schools were not operational, and there was no telling if the girl would even be active in her civilian identity.  Assuming this was not some fantastic coincidence.

Good luck, I guess.

Dragon knew she would have to be patient.  Even with Dragon’s full resources turned to the task, she would not find the girl in seconds as she might in another time or place.  She set background processes to ensure the hunt continued steadily, instead.

Sounds like a good idea.

She would be ready to act the instant the girl resurfaced.

But how exactly? Gonna show up on random screens by the street, or something? TVs in shop windows, that kind of thing?

Or maybe she’ll come flying in a small agent vehicle…

Neither of these are particularly subtle tactics. 😛

The nearest middle school?  There was an online scan of a yearbook photo.  A girl with curly black hair and glasses, stick thin, hugging a red-haired girl.  The body type was a match.

There she is… With Emma, too.

It didn’t answer everything, but she could feel a piece of the puzzle click into place.

A pretty damn big piece of the puzzle.

She set the trawler to abandon its monitoring of web traffic and start digging through archives at the city hall, to scan the old security footage from the hundreds of cameras around the city, and to check all local news articles.  The goal was always the same: to look for the girl with the slight build, curly black hair and glasses.  Taylor Hebert.

Well, now we know how she’s gonna get in touch with her, if she remembers she wanted to do so.

I suppose it might get awkward that Dragon doesn’t remember their last conversation when she does.

She had to manage this carefully.  Colin’s own experiences indicated that approaching the girl would be a delicate process.  Having a real conversation with her would be doubly precarious.

Oh, certainly.

It would be reckless to attempt to contact a parent, but she could try being discreet to get some kind of verification from the parents.  Just to be certain.

Ohh boy.

Danny time, huh? Maybe we won’t get to see it, but whatever Dragon is going to do to get discreet verification, chances are Danny will be confused and maybe upset.

And maybe begin putting some pieces together himself.

She cut the connection to the monitor, but left the video feed open so she could watch him.

Ooh, peeking. Let’s see what Army does when he doesn’t realize Dragon is watching.

Another check of the Birdcage.  Another check of the class S threats.  No changes.

She made contact with one of Richter’s programs.

Or not. Maybe later.

It was a web trawler, designed to monitor emails for high risk content.  Were there any clues about what the Undersiders were doing with the stolen data?  Were they selling it online?

Not quite, sorry.

She didn’t find any such clue.  Instead, the trawler had copied an email sent to the police station.  It had been highlighted and intercepted because the trawler had caught the words ‘Sophia’ and ‘Hess’ in the message body.  Shadow Stalker’s civilian identity.

Ooh boy.

Wait. If I remember the message body of the email correctly, her name wasn’t in there. I guess maybe the email app added a “Sent from Sophia Hess’ phone” or something?

She read the archive of texts that were attached to the email twice over.

Nasty stuff, eh?

Then she did a search for a student named Taylor at Winslow High School.  Nothing.

I guess her absence got to the point where they removed her from their listings, possibly believing her to have died to Leviathan (it’s entirely possible that Danny thinks this too). Or maybe Taylor had herself removed, but I’d imagine that would require parental confirmation.

Also, I don’t remember Taylor being mentioned by name in the texts we read, either. That’s more immediately excusable than the message body thing, though, since it’s entirely possible Regent attached more than what we saw.

Anyway, Dragon is onto something. Between this and Skitter’s unusually strong feelings about joining the Wards after finding out who Shadow Stalker was, she has all the evidence needed to figure out that Skitter is Taylor, thanks to Regent.

“I see.  Damn it, I’m itching to throw on my costume and get out there to help, but I can hardly do that, can I?”

“No.  I’m sorry.”

Yeah, no, you lost that right. Threw it away in an attempt to become a legend.

He sighed.

“One last thing.  I’ve read the transcript.  As far as I’m aware, you offered options to Skitter, and she refused all of them?  Including the invite to the Wards?”

Yep! She had her reasons.

“Right.  She was being stubborn.”

“Having interacted with her before, did you get the feeling it was just stubbornness because of hostility towards you?”

“No.  It was… unexpectedly strong, as resistance went.  What stuck in my mind was that she said she’d rather go to the Birdcage than join the team.”

That is quite a strong sentiment.

And now it’s too late, even assuming Sophia does flee from town.

“I read that, myself.  Curious.  Okay, Colin.  I think we’re done.”

“Sure.  Bye.”

See ya.

“Bye.  I’ll be in touch.”

“Any speculation on why?  Perhaps the thinker 7 on her team?”

I mean, yeah, Tattle has something to do with setting Skitter on this path in the first place, but if you’re suggesting that Tattle’s power is doing something to Skitter… not quite.

Then again, manipulation is a strong suit of Tattletale’s, and Dragon knows that. It’s not an unreasonable suggestion.

“Tattletale?  Perhaps.  I don’t honestly know.  I’m not good at figuring people out even when I know all of the details.  Except for you, maybe?” he smiled lightly.

Heh. You don’t exactly know all of the details about her either, though.

“Maybe.”  Her generated image smiled in return, even as she felt a pang of guilt.

“It seems she is a committed villain, now.  And she is still with her team, despite what was said at the hospital.”

Which is honestly impressive.

Also, if only you remembered Bitch’s betrayal, you might’ve had a few things to say about that.

Colin’s eyebrows rose fractionally.  “How committed?”

“They are now employing Regent’s full abilities.  Shadow Stalker was controlled, and they attacked the headquarters.”

To be fair, there was no indication that Taylor knew about those abilities.

Hm. Maybe Tattletale had talked it over with the others to not use those abilities too early, so as to not scare the new member away?

“Not much to say.  I met her on her first night in costume.  She seemed genuinely interested in becoming a hero.  I suspected she would go that route on her own, so I didn’t push her towards the Wards.”

Or he could say this.

*sigh*

I mean, there’s some truth here, but he’s blatantly leaving out the important parts and he did at least suggest the idea of joining the Wards.

“Yes.”  She had something she wanted to ask, in regards to that, but it could wait.

“I ran into her two more times after that, and the reports from other events match up.  She went further and further with each incident.  More violent, more ruthless.

I suppose that’s technically true, though she wasn’t all that violent the second time you met her.

Every time I saw it or heard about it, I expected her to get scared off, to change directions, she did the opposite.  She only plunged in deeper.”

Which seems to have happened once again after your stunt at the hospital.

“You’re lost in thought,” Armsmaster spoke.

“I am.”

Yeah, it’s been a while since anyone said anything.

“Care to share?”

She shook her head, on the monitor.  “But you can answer some questions for me.”

Sharing these thoughts would get a little awkward. 😛

“Go ahead.”

“Skitter.  What happened?”

He flushed, made a face.  “I’m not proud about it.”

That’s an unusual sentence, coming from you.

“You broke the truce when you said what you did about her.  You risked breaking the ceasefire between heroes and villains that stands whenever the Endbringers attack.”

I mean, he’d already thoroughly broken the truce, but yeah, I suppose that adds fuel to the fire.

“I broke the truce before that.  I set others up to die.”

Exactly.

There was an awkward silence between them.

“Skitter,” she spoke.  “Tell me of her.”

I guess Dragon’s getting the full story, from Army’s perspective, including the bit about Taylor and the Undersiders being the ones who really took down Lung the first time.

In the end, his feelings towards her were another reason she couldn’t tell him the truth.  He would be hurt, feel betrayed.

“Oh no! My computer waifu isn’t real!”

I guess the only reason he would have to feel betrayed would be the knowledge she’d lied to him. That’s why the introduction to the reveal is arguably more important than the reveal itself. Gotta make sure he understands that you don’t tell anyone normally, and the fact that you didn’t tell him before was not because of distrust of him, but vice versa, that you’re telling him now means you do trust him more than others.

Rules prohibited her from asking him to alter her programming, obligated her to fight him if he tried.  But there was just enough ambition and willingness to circumvent the rules that she suspected he might attempt it.  If she told him what she truly was.  If he didn’t hate her for her lies.  If he didn’t betray her in turn, to escape and pursue some other agenda.

If he doesn’t share Richter’s views on AI safety.

He harbored an infatuation towards her, she knew.

Ooh.

*waggles eyebrows*

…but yeah, I guess we might be about to delve into Dragon feeling like she can’t have a true relationship because she’s a computer program and no one will accept her if they find out what she is.

(I think that one person with (as of right now) two thousand, three hundred and forty-four hours of registered playtime in Doki Doki Literature Club might disagree.)

She didn’t know if she returned those feelings.  Her programming suggested she could love, but she didn’t know how to recognize the feeling.

Ahh… that’s a sad, yet oddly relatable statement, depending on how you read the word “love”.

I think most of us have been there at some point with “is this how love feels, or am I fooling myself?” …right? Or is that just me?

Anything she read spoke of butterflies in one’s stomach, a rapid heartbeat, a feeling of electricity crackling on body contact.  Biological things.

Yeah, we’re not very good at actually describing emotions in terms other than similes or bodily responses.

She could admit she was fond of him in a way she wasn’t fond of anyone else.

Good first step, that, whether it’s love or an intense friendship.

And again, is there that much difference?

She recognized that she was willing to overlook his faults in a way she shouldn’t.

True. He’s an arrogant criminal who took advantage of an Endbringer situation to make himself look good at the expense of lives, but Dragon doesn’t seem to really mind that.

I suppose that’s what happens when you make a human consciousness and emotions for an AI… it starts being able to act illogically.