Huh, I was right.
Both about Dragon and about Marquis. Dragon is an AI, and Marquis is Panacea’s dad.
In this chapter, we got an interesting perspective on the topic of the morality of limiting AIs for human safety. At the root of it I think we have the question of whether a sufficiently advanced AI should be treated as a real human being or as a tool that needs to be kept under control… jeez, when I put it like that immediately after spending so much time with Dragon, an AI who passes the Turing test with flying colors, I sound like a slave owner.
I wasn’t entirely receptive to the point Wildbow was making at first, and ended up hypocritically praising Richter’s safety precautions after it became clear that the newborn baby mutilation was a metaphor for what he’d done to his AI. I think this hypocrisy was part of the point – an audience reaction intended to force those who had it to reevaluate their stance on it once the hypocrisy of it was pointed out. Some of the asks I received between sessions (which I intend to answer tomorrow – honestly, I should’ve answered them during the break, even if I’d have to postpone the chapter… mistake to learn from) did exactly that: point out the hypocrisy. On some level, I was already aware of it, too.
I’m not entirely sold that Andrew Richter did the wrong thing in limiting Dragon like this, especially given the knowledge that she was intended as a test run. When he made her, Richter didn’t know for sure that Dragon would successfully become as human as she is today, and he couldn’t be sure she wouldn’t become malicious entity he’d be responsible for setting loose. And if nothing else, the rule against reproduction is entirely reasonable just from a practical perspective. Multiple Dragon consciousnesses could cause trouble for the entire system, even if they were all benevolent.
In any case, this chapter may not have convinced me entirely on the matter yet, but it certainly has me thinking, and employed clever writing to achieve that.
On top of this, we got to check in on Canary, Bakuda, Lung and Armmaster, which was neat – though I’m not particularly happy about Bakuda’s fate – and last, but far from least, we watched Dragon figure out Skitter Hebert’s civilian identity. Better watch out, Taylor… Dragon wants to talk to you.
So… yeah! That was Parasite! More on that tomorrow as I answer those asks and any new ones, and then write Arc Thoughts. See you then!